Crappie fishing reels - Buying guide, Reviews and Comparison


If you want to find the best fishing gear, but you don’t have time to go through the buying tips and reviews prepared by our research team, this short paragraph should tell you everything you need to know about the best crappie fishing reels. After analyzing a lot of feedback coming both from amateur and professional fishermen, we have concluded that the FyshFlyer Fire Premium is the best as it features a high-performance front drag system, four ball bearings constructed out of stainless steel as well as one bearing for instant anti-reverse. Besides, the handle of this model can be changed depending on your hand orientation or the person using it at some point or the other. If the FyshFlyer Fire Premium is unavailable, you should consider the Mr. Crappie Slab Shaker as it is a reliable alternative both in terms of performance and quality.



Our top choices


The best products in this category will be showcased below. We’ve gone through a lot of info about them and even did our best at estimating the value they offer for the price. In the end, this selection was based on the social media impact as well as the user feedback that these models have acquired over the years.



FyshFlyer Fire Premium 


The FyshFlyer Fire is one of the most critically acclaimed units in the line and that shouldn’t come as a surprise considering that it’s also one of the most affordable reels for crappie. From what we’ve seen, the item usually costs less than forty dollars, regardless of the online retailer of your choice.

Aside from the fact that it is financially accessible, the model is rather appealing to users thanks to features such as the high-performance drag system and exchangeable handle, as well as the fact that it comes with five ball bearings made of stainless steel, one of which is for instant stop anti-reverse.

Based on the feedback garnered by the FyshFlyer Fire Premium, it appears that it is one of the top recommended choices of people who fish in freshwater and inshore saltwater, some of whom were kind to underline that the reel has a smooth action and casts wonderfully.


Geared with 4+1 stainless steel ball bearings, this fishing reel delivers the smoothness and speed you want when trying to land the catch. The ball bearings offer durability and support smooth operations.

Thanks to the extra-light, graphite rotor alloy, you are assured of easy turning of the spool with every crank of the handle. No need to worry about the system suddenly getting stuck when the action turns intense.

With the non-slip, soft-touch knob, you wouldn’t have to expend too much effort just to run the whole reel system when the fish chooses to put up a big fight to resist being landed.

You can make the most of the single anti-reverse bearing, which keeps the line flow smooth and consistent without forming knots in case you accidentally lay out too quickly.

You’ll also love the control you get from the smooth yet powerful drag performance across all settings.


The product only ships in a single color of blue, so customers do not have any choice on the matter.

Buy from for ($18.99)





Mr. Crappie Slab Shaker 


The Slab Shaker can be purchased in three main sizes, depending on what you have in mind. For instance, the MCS50 can be utilized with a very light line, making it one of the favorite choices of individuals who plan to fish in conditions such as nearby rivers and other areas of this sort.

The two other sizes can be utilized with heavier line, but be sure to correlate your purpose and fishing technique with the reel before choosing one over the other.

The main advantage of picking the Slab Shaker consists of the fact that its body, spool, and rotor are all made of graphite, making it lightweight and durable. Aside from the fact that this reel is a sight for sore eyes, it also comes with a 32-point multistop antireverse feature, which is undoubtedly convenient.

As is the case with other models, the hand orientation of this alternative can be customized by the end-user.


Engineered for use with an extremely light line, this option offers a suitable solution for those who are ultra-light spin anglers. It even ships with its own Mr. Crappie premium line.

Because of how it is geared to be as lightweight as possible, this model features a graphite body, spool, and rotor, which work nicely together without adding a significant amount of heft to the entire fishing setup.

You can enjoy the benefits of using the 32-point multi-stop anti-reverse that ensures no stuck up lines and accumulation of line-breaking friction on the spool.

Adjustments can be made to configure this choice to accommodate the needs of both right and left-handed anglers.

With its thin, compact gear box, this fishing reel provides a low-profile option that won’t hinder your handling of the rod.


This model does not carry any embellishments that the higher-priced models have, but it does get the job done as expected.

Buy from for ($16.78)





Lew’s Fishing Mr. Crappie S01 


If you’re just beginning your fishing adventure and have little to no idea when it comes to selecting a cutting-edge reel, perhaps you ought to have a look at the specs and looks of the Lew’s Fishing Crappie S01. In spite of the fact that it’s significantly more traditional compared to its competitors, the unit does precisely what it is supposed to do without advancing any technical difficulties to users.

The frame and spool of this option are made of graphite, allowing you to take advantage of the low weight and good construction of the product.

Some of the people who were kind enough to provide feedback about the Lew’s Fishing Crappie S01 say that it seems to have been designed for drop jigging, which means that it’s perfect for complete beginners and children. Unlike some of the other items we’ve showcased in our selection, this one comes pre-set for the left-hand orientation.


You’ll appreciate the lightweight yet strong graphite spool and frame on this model. They do not add a significant amount of weight to the fishing rig but are still capable of performing as designed.

With its large arbor design, this reel guarantees fewer incidences of line twisting when the element is released quite rapidly. Line recovery is increased to reduce the incidences of bird’s nests or tangling.

You can tell when the fish starts to bite even when you leave the rig unattended because this particular unit features a clicker to serve as an alarm that the wide-range, multi-disc drag has been engaged by fish on the line.

Geared with the necessary protection from corrosion when used in brackish and saltwater settings, this model also comes with a sturdy, die-cast aluminum frame that delivers a wobble-free performance.


One customer says there are no instructions on how to transform the reel from a left-handed to a right-handed orientation.

Buy from for ($15.99)





Buying guide


Any well-seasoned fisherman knows that he or she ought to use a spinning or baitcasting reel for crappie fishing. However, since we’ve noticed that there are many options available on the current market, it might be more or less difficult for you to make up your mind on a certain product. Keep on reading to find the right features of most reels for crappie fishing and be sure to correlate them with your expectations and purpose.


In most cases, whether you intend to catch larger or smaller fish, you ought to focus on choosing a reel that’s made of metal, graphite, or cast aluminum. If the gears are all metal, you’re on the right track. Based on our research, plastic can’t handle the amount of abuse a reel should be able to take over time so stick with models that have as many durable components as possible.



If you know your way around fishing gear by now, you’re probably aware of the fact that the more bearings in a crappie reel, the better. With fewer bearings, the unit will be harder to control and might even end up being jerky. Therefore, if what you have in mind is stability and using your equipment correctly all the time, just pick a model that comes with at least four bearings or more.


Purpose and experience level

If what you have in mind is to fish just crappie, you probably won’t have to go through too much trouble when selecting the right reel. On the other hand, if what you’re looking for is an entirely capable multi-purpose alternative, perhaps you might want to choose a light-medium alternative. While ultra-light options are excellent for crappie and panfish, they might offer less impressive results if you want to use them also in rivers and lakes where other species live, as well.

In the beginning, it might be a good idea to get a model that has managed to gather some of the most remarkable crappie fishing reels reviews but try to stick to a versatile unit so that you’re able to go on fishing trips and use it for various other fish. If you have more than enough experience and know what to look for in fishing equipment, in general, you might already own multiple reels for every fishing occasion.



1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (4 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)